Motivational Enhancement Therapy and Cognitive Behavioral Therapy for Adolescent Cannabis Users: 5 Sessions
Background on the
CYT Cooperative Agreement
MET/CBT5 was developed as a brief intervention to be tested at four
treatment sites within the Cannabis Youth Treatment study. Section III of
this manual describes the rationale for choosing the elements of the
MET/CBT5 therapy. The following description illustrates the context in
which MET/CBT5 was developed.
Goals and Objectives
The purpose of the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services
Administration (SAMHSA) Center for Substance Abuse Treatment (CSAT)
Cannabis Youth Treatment Cooperative Agreement was to test the relative
effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of a variety of interventions targeted at
reducing/eliminating marijuana use and associated problems in adolescents
and to provide validated models of these interventions to the treatment field.
The target population was adolescents with cannabis use disorders of abuse or
dependence, as defined by the American Psychiatric Association (1994), who
were assessed as appropriate for treatment in outpatient settings.
Overview of Study
The study was conducted in collaboration with staff from Chestnut
Health Systems (CHS–MC) in Bloomington and Madison County, Illinois,
the University of Connecticut Health Center (UCHC) in Farmington,
Connecticut, Operation Parental Awareness and Responsibility (PAR) in St.
Petersburg, Florida, and the Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia (CHOP),
Pennsylvania. It involved five manual-based, expert-supported treatment
conditions:
MET/CBT5—This is the five-session treatment described in this
manual. It comprises two individual sessions of motivational
enhancement therapy (MET) and three group sessions of
cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT). The MET sessions focus on
factors that motivate clients to change. In the CBT sessions,
clients learn skills to cope with problems and meet their
needs in ways that do not involve turning to marijuana or alcohol.
MET/CBT5+CBT7—This treatment is composed of the complete
MET/CBT5 treatment combined with seven supplemental
cognitive behavioral sessions covering additional coping skills
topics.
FSN—The Family Support Network (FSN) treatment consists of
the MET5+CBT7 treatment combined with additional support for
families (home visits, parent education meetings, parent support
group), aftercare, and case management.
ACRA—The Adolescent Community Reinforcement Approach
(ACRA) is composed of 12 individual sessions with an adolescent
and the adolescent’s parent, caregiver, or concerned other. The
focus is on learning alternative skills to cope with problems and
meet needs with an emphasis on the adolescent’s environment.
Concerted effort is made to change the environmental contingen-cies—
both positive and negative—related to substance use.
MDFT—Multidimensional Family Therapy (MDFT) is a family-focused
treatment that includes 12 weekly sessions to work
individually with adolescents and their families. MDFT focuses on
family roles, other problem areas, and their interactions.
These treatments can also be grouped in three different ways. First,
they vary by mode, with the first three being combinations of individual and
group approaches and the last two being purely individual treatment approach-es.
Second, the MET/CBT and ACRA interventions were based on behavioral
treatment approaches, while the FSN and MDFT interventions were based on
family treatment approaches. Third, the treatment conditions were expected
to vary in terms of resource intensity and cost, with the MET/CBT5
intervention expected to be the least costly therapy to implement.
At each site, approximately 150 adolescents were systematically
assigned to one of three conditions. At ARC and PAR, they were assigned to
the brief MET/CBT5 or to one of the two other individual/group
combinations, MET/CBT5+CBT7 or FSN. At CHS–MC and CHOP, adoles-cents
were assigned to the brief MET/CBT5 treatment or one of the two
individual approaches, ACRA or MDFT. Thus, all five conditions were repli-cated
in two or more sites, with the MET/CBT5 condition implemented at
all four sites. All clients were assessed at intake and at 3, 6, and 9 months.
To validate clients’ responses, urine tests and collateral assessments are
also done at intake and at 3 and 6 months.
The general research design document prepared by Dennis and
colleagues describes the overall research plan in greater detail (Dennis,
Titus, Diamond, Donaldson, Godley, Tims, Webb, Kaminer, Babor, French,
Godley, Hamilton, Liddle & Scott, under review). The project’s Web site
(www.chestnut.org/CYT) can be accessed for further information about the
CYT project.
Client and Provider Information
Target Population
MET/CBT5 is designed for the treatment of adolescents between the
ages of 12 and 18 with problems related to marijuana use, as indicated by
one of the following:
Meeting criteria for cannabis abuse or dependence
Experiencing problems (including emotional, physical, legal,
social, or academic problems) associated with marijuana use
Using marijuana at least weekly for 3 months.
Although this treatment includes suggestions for addressing both
drug and alcohol use, it is not designed for treating adolescents with poly-substance
dependence or those who are heavily using other substances as
well as marijuana. In the CYT study, adolescents were excluded from the
study who drank alcohol on 45 or more of the previous 90 days or who used
another drug on 13 or more of the previous 90 days.
MET/CBT5 should not be used to treat adolescents
Requiring a level of care that is higher than outpatient treatment
With a social anxiety disorder severe enough to prevent participa-tion
in group therapy sessions
With a severe conduct disorder
With an acute psychological disorder severe enough to prevent
full participation in treatment.
In the CYT study, this treatment was effectively implemented with
adolescents with mixed demographic characteristics such as race, age,
socioeconomic group, and gender, as well as from different geographic
regions. When treating clients, therapists need to be culturally aware of
and sensitive to the client group so they can provide relevant examples
and use language that is understood by the clients in the therapy session.
Likely referral sources of potential MET/CBT5 clients are parents,
the justice system, school personnel, and medical or mental health care
providers. Self-referral is infrequent.
Level of Care
MET/CBT5 is appropriate for use as either an outpatient treatment
(ASAM level 1) or early intervention (ASAM level 0.5).
MET/CBT5 can be used by organizations that provide outpatient care,
including mental health clinics, youth social service agencies, and mental
health private practice settings. Other organizations such as community
centers, schools, or general medical settings may appropriately implement
MET/CBT5 if they have properly trained staff. Medical settings may be partic-ularly
well suited for implementation of MET/CBT5 as an early intervention.